Last week, my pastor send me a link to an e-book he had found written by Steve Hays and posted free on a reformed theology website (monergism.com). His hope was that these writings would help me in my wrestling in the canon. Weighing in at over thirty one thousand words, there is more material here than I can cover in a single post. Therefore, I plan to make the rest of this post an overview of the text and submit my initial thoughts.
One of the first statements the text makes is "Over the years I’ve written a number of occasional pieces on the Protestant canon of Scripture....John Hendryx has kindly offered to collate this material in the form of an ebook."
This is an extremely accurate statement, and even a quick reading will find plenty of evidence of this fact. Each chapter is an "article" it itself, many laying out their own copy of references and the like. Chapters range from fully written out articles with quotes inline to what appears to be just talking points and/or notes from a talk. Without the background of a literary scholar, some sections of the text made very little sense to me, while others were written giving enough background to be understood easily.
The tone for many of the articles is casual, with the author's opinion of Catholic and liberal scholars spelled out with phrases like: "herd mentality of Roman Catholics", "Catholic apologists have Catholicism etched on their spectacles", "there are copycat liberals who simply regurgitate the latest fad in Bible criticism". While I find such comments detracting from the text itself, one should note (somewhat mitigatingly) that the text wasn't written as a cohesive text for publication, but as an assortment of pieces written over the years to various groups.
The chapter titles themselves are a fair description of what is covered in the text:
Chapter 1 - Retroengineering the canon of Scripture
Chapter 2 - Approaches to the canon of Scripture
Chapter 3 - Canonical criteria
Chapter 4 - How we got the New Testament
Chapter 5 - The Bible as autobiography
Chapter 6 - The OT witness to the OT canon
Chapter 7 - Hypothetical arguments for the Catholic canon
Chapter 8 - “The Magisterium in the NT”
Chapter 9 - Hebrews
Chapter 10 - Enoch & Jude
Chapter 11 - Pseudepigrapha
Chapter 12 - James and Jude
Chapter 13 - The legendary Alexandrian canon
Chapter 14 - For Further Reading
From what I can tell, the primary argument of the text can roughly be summarized as:
The canon of scripture is not an externally defined thing, but flows from the text itself. Given bits of the canon, one can reason the canonically of another section in a way that is similar to mathematics or the laws of physics. The evidence one uses to reason about the canonically of scripture are things like: authorship of a given book, intertextuality between the books, common sources/kinship/affiliation of the authors, etc.
I am very glad that another Protestant considers this topic important enough to spend a significant amount of time and text wrestling with it. In my experience, this is not a common at all. However, I don't find many of the author's arguments persuasive and am troubled with some of his statements. Unless things change while discussing the text in further posts, I don't believe the answer to my canon questions will be found here.
Showing posts with label canon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label canon. Show all posts
Sunday, June 12, 2011
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
The Canon: Root of the issue (Part II)
Last post, I laid out five common (or uncommon) views on who determines canon of scripture. I also hinted that I currently don't fall into one of these (or any really) right now. Walking through each argument and showing the faults I find in each should shed some light in the "abyss" I find myself.
1) The early church (Catholic)
The cop out answer for why I find fault with this view can seen in the fact that I'm neither Catholic or Orthdox of some flavor. One holding this view almost directly leads to converting to one of these branches of the Church. The only way somebody could hold this view and not convert would involve the claim that that authority was lost at some point. I find this unlikely; if God invested a group of leaders such authority as is claimed, the removal of such authority would likely involve some sort of cataclysmic event in church history. Since I see no such evidence for such an event, and I must conclude the early church did not have such authority.
Laying out the full reasons I am not Catholic is a post (or set of posts) in itself; considering the theological state I find myself in, it would also be unwise and/or premature.
2) The early church
This view holds that God gave special authority to a specific group for this one time decision. Beyond a generic dislike that comes from being a programs related to special cases, I find this view lacking. In almost all of recorded history found in scriptures, special favor for momentous events involves the supernatural. The presence of God involved things like the Sun standing still, people rising from the dead (or dying suddenly), fire from heaven, etc. In history, I find no such occurrences. Much of the record seems to involves various groups coming up with various proposals and hammering out details over time. For God to give this group special authority, and then act in a way singularly different than most miracles of recorded church history is a strong claim; for me to find assurance in such a claim I need more evidence to wrap my brain (and heart) around.
3) The individual believer
The most obvious fault with this theory is the billion[1] Catholics and 300 million[2] Eastern Orthodox Christians in the world today (ignoring the masses found throughout history). Even a very conservative 1% estimate of that amount being ones who are "saved" gives 13 million souls who disagree with the protestant canon. If it was obvious, a non-trivial number of them should have objected at some point.
Ignoring that for a moment, the next fault is the fact that the church operated in some form for 1600 years roughly before the reformation and the removal of the old testament books in question. Even if only 1% of the Christians over those years were really "saved", and 1% of their complaints were written down and preserved, I should be able to point to somebody who found some books "obviously" uninspired.
Beyond both of these thought experiments, one can look to the reformers themselves. It is a well recorded fact that Luther wanted to remove some books of the new testament for some parts of his life. Some Lutheran churches still order these books late in their canons. However, Calvin for example found no such flaw in these books. If the canon itself is as obvious as this view suggests, shouldn't these two patriarchs of the reformation agree?
4) "A fallible collection of infallible books"
This view throws in the towel in any claim of authority in determining canon. In addition to being intellectually unsatisfying, there is a serious if not fatal flaw in reasoning about theology that springs from this view.
Assume some doctrine that can be found in scripture but is not completely spelled out. I like communion, so I'll go with that. Communion has many things stated about it in scripture, but for example it never states how often one should partake. What if there was a second letter to the Romans sitting in some library somewhere, that states that a church must take communion every week? Our canon is a fallible collection of books, so it is possible that inspired letter is not in our canon. This means one holding to this view can not be 100% certain of any doctrine, as there could be a missing book that describes it further. The possibility of a book in canon that is not inspired should evoke enough fear of heresy that I shouldn't have to spell out that other possibility directly.
5) A particular group
The view begs to have the blank filled in, which group do you believe God invested authority into determining canon? A generic case of "The early church", many of the same criticisms apply. The group given such authority would either:
a) Still have that authority, and make the claims that the Catholic/Orthodox churches do
b) Have had but lost that authority, I can't believe loosing that authority wouldn't come without a recognizable mark on history
c) Had that authority for a short (set) period of time. All other short term investing of God's authority/power/Spirit come with some sort of visible signs, by why not this one?
And thus by excluding the vast majority of standard theories related to the canon and the authority to determine its bounds, I find myself in the abyss somewhat. I currently work under the assumption of the 66 protestant canon, but do not have a principled reason for this assumption. Thus, this blog and this (rather long) entry.
1) The early church (Catholic)
The cop out answer for why I find fault with this view can seen in the fact that I'm neither Catholic or Orthdox of some flavor. One holding this view almost directly leads to converting to one of these branches of the Church. The only way somebody could hold this view and not convert would involve the claim that that authority was lost at some point. I find this unlikely; if God invested a group of leaders such authority as is claimed, the removal of such authority would likely involve some sort of cataclysmic event in church history. Since I see no such evidence for such an event, and I must conclude the early church did not have such authority.
Laying out the full reasons I am not Catholic is a post (or set of posts) in itself; considering the theological state I find myself in, it would also be unwise and/or premature.
2) The early church
This view holds that God gave special authority to a specific group for this one time decision. Beyond a generic dislike that comes from being a programs related to special cases, I find this view lacking. In almost all of recorded history found in scriptures, special favor for momentous events involves the supernatural. The presence of God involved things like the Sun standing still, people rising from the dead (or dying suddenly), fire from heaven, etc. In history, I find no such occurrences. Much of the record seems to involves various groups coming up with various proposals and hammering out details over time. For God to give this group special authority, and then act in a way singularly different than most miracles of recorded church history is a strong claim; for me to find assurance in such a claim I need more evidence to wrap my brain (and heart) around.
3) The individual believer
The most obvious fault with this theory is the billion[1] Catholics and 300 million[2] Eastern Orthodox Christians in the world today (ignoring the masses found throughout history). Even a very conservative 1% estimate of that amount being ones who are "saved" gives 13 million souls who disagree with the protestant canon. If it was obvious, a non-trivial number of them should have objected at some point.
Ignoring that for a moment, the next fault is the fact that the church operated in some form for 1600 years roughly before the reformation and the removal of the old testament books in question. Even if only 1% of the Christians over those years were really "saved", and 1% of their complaints were written down and preserved, I should be able to point to somebody who found some books "obviously" uninspired.
Beyond both of these thought experiments, one can look to the reformers themselves. It is a well recorded fact that Luther wanted to remove some books of the new testament for some parts of his life. Some Lutheran churches still order these books late in their canons. However, Calvin for example found no such flaw in these books. If the canon itself is as obvious as this view suggests, shouldn't these two patriarchs of the reformation agree?
4) "A fallible collection of infallible books"
This view throws in the towel in any claim of authority in determining canon. In addition to being intellectually unsatisfying, there is a serious if not fatal flaw in reasoning about theology that springs from this view.
Assume some doctrine that can be found in scripture but is not completely spelled out. I like communion, so I'll go with that. Communion has many things stated about it in scripture, but for example it never states how often one should partake. What if there was a second letter to the Romans sitting in some library somewhere, that states that a church must take communion every week? Our canon is a fallible collection of books, so it is possible that inspired letter is not in our canon. This means one holding to this view can not be 100% certain of any doctrine, as there could be a missing book that describes it further. The possibility of a book in canon that is not inspired should evoke enough fear of heresy that I shouldn't have to spell out that other possibility directly.
5) A particular group
The view begs to have the blank filled in, which group do you believe God invested authority into determining canon? A generic case of "The early church", many of the same criticisms apply. The group given such authority would either:
a) Still have that authority, and make the claims that the Catholic/Orthodox churches do
b) Have had but lost that authority, I can't believe loosing that authority wouldn't come without a recognizable mark on history
c) Had that authority for a short (set) period of time. All other short term investing of God's authority/power/Spirit come with some sort of visible signs, by why not this one?
And thus by excluding the vast majority of standard theories related to the canon and the authority to determine its bounds, I find myself in the abyss somewhat. I currently work under the assumption of the 66 protestant canon, but do not have a principled reason for this assumption. Thus, this blog and this (rather long) entry.
The Canon: Root of the issue (Part I)
Wikipedia describes the cannon as: "...a list of books considered to be authoritative as scripture by a particular religious community." Christians refine this definition to be the books divinely inspired and revealed by God. Since scripture itself is interpreted to lay out various doctrines, what we believe about canon has a non-trivial effect on our beliefs.
Since Christian's don't believe that all of scriptures fell from the sky completed, nor were they written by a one person in a given period of time, some entity must be given authority to determine what is included and excluded. Some entities that I have honestly seen put forth include (in no particular order):
Since Christian's don't believe that all of scriptures fell from the sky completed, nor were they written by a one person in a given period of time, some entity must be given authority to determine what is included and excluded. Some entities that I have honestly seen put forth include (in no particular order):
- The early church (Catholic) - The authority given to Peter from Christ passed down through the rightful successors gave the respective councils authority to determine scripture.
- The early church - God chose to give a respective council one time authority to determine scripture. However, decisions before/after by the same people/group do not have the same authority
- The individual believer (via the Holy Spirit) - Any Christian should be able to tell if a given work is part of the canon just as a person knows the difference between sweet and sour.
- "A fallible collection of infallible books" - We have no way of being certain that the collection is correct, just that a given book is inspired or not.
- A particular group - God gave special authority to this group to make the determination. This is really a generalization of the second early church view. Common groups given authority include the early reformer (Luther/Calvin,/etc), leadership of ones specific church or denomination, etc.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)